BMW Denies Accuracy Of DUH Report Which Found Real-World 3-Series NOx Emissions 7 Times Above Legal Limit

The German luxury auto manufacturer BMW has denied allegations from the environmental group DUH that engine management software cut power to a system filtering nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions during real-world road testing of a 3-Series diesel car — thus allowing for NOx emissions some 7 times higher than the legal limit.

The German environmental group’s allegations pertain to the results of 8 separate road tests, so there’s presumably something to them — rather than the illegal emissions levels simply being a “fluke” of some kind.

“The test involved a BMW 320d manufactured  in 2016. DUH tested the car in the lab and on the road and found that at engine speeds of 2000 rpm or less, emissions were at or below official levels. But once engine speed exceeded 3000 rpm, emission — particularly nitrogen oxide levels — spiked to more than 7 times permitted levels,” Steve Hanley summarizes on CleanTechnica.

“At a press conference in Berlin this week, the group announced it believes the exhaust gas recirculation system is switched off by the engine control software at higher engine speeds. ‘There is clear evidence that in this car, an unauthorized defeat device is installed,’ said DUH managing director Jürgen Resch.”

“The results give very clear signs of unlawful defeat devices in the engine control software,” stated Resch at a news conference. “The vehicle must provide for fully functional exhaust gas cleaning in all normal operating situations.”

Reuters provides more details: “The 2-litre, 320d car, which is designed to meet the latest Euro 6 standards on emissions, exceeded the statutory cap of 80 milligrammes of NOx per kilometer by an average of 2.6 times in 8 road tests and even by 7.2 times when the car’s speed was increased by 10%. … However, in a separate set of static roller-bed tests also conducted by the DUH in October, the results of which were not independently verified, the same BMW car’s NOx emissions remained significantly below the 80 milligrammes per kilometer limit at normal speeds and when the speed was increased by 10%, the group said.”

But I guess that BMW execs don’t have any idea why such a discrepancy would exist. … As one would presumably expect, company representatives have denied any “wrongdoing.”

The BMW statement read: “There are no activities of technical provisions to affect the test mode used to measure emissions — that means that our exhaust systems are active both on the test bed and in practice.”

This statement was followed by public comments from BMW’s development chief, Klaus Froehlich, that the allegations were part of a “campaign” against BMW.

The German Transport Ministry and the KBA motor vehicle watchdog have been asked by DUH to review the BMW 320d model, and also to issue a mandatory recall for affected models if the results are verified.






About the Author

‘s background is predominantly in geopolitics and history, but he has an obsessive interest in pretty much everything. After an early life spent in the Imperial Free City of Dortmund, James followed the river Ruhr to Cofbuokheim, where he attended the University of Astnide. And where he also briefly considered entering the coal mining business. He currently writes for a living, on a broad variety of subjects, ranging from science, to politics, to military history, to renewable energy. You can follow his work on Google+.