Nature Walks Improve Learning More than City Walks

Environmental psychology researchers at the University of Michigan have confirmed what many have long-suspected: spending time in a natural setting is good for the brain (at least for its ability to retain important information). Study subjects learned better after a walk in nature than after a walk in a dense urban setting. Conversely, previous studies ( also conducted by Marc Berman et al) have shown that living in a dense urban environment actually impairs cognition and self-control.

It is believed that urban environments present an excess of stimuli, information and choices to our brains, leaving them fatigued. This spate of recent research comes at a time in human history when (for the first time) a majority of people live in cities.





Researchers note that our harried urban lives afford us little time for mental refreshment, and so we take numerous small breaks (“micro moments”). But these do not provide the benefits that longer breaks provide–in fact, they  make our brains more fatigued in the long run. But research shows that a walk in Nature can restore our brains and improve learning.

Greater Tokyo Area, the world’s most populous urban area with about 35 million people.

Cities constantly present our brains with a diversity of new experiences. Unlike the diversity in Nature, however, these urban experiences can be disruptive, stressful and often accompanied by negative emotional states. These effects tend to impair basic cognitive functions.

Studies conducted at the University of California, San Francisco on rats (perhaps not ironically), showed that new experiences were accompanied by new neural firing patterns in the brains of the rodents. However, only when the rats were allowed to take a break from these new stimuli were they able to process the experiences (i.e., the new neural patterns) in a way that allowed for retention of the experience.

The non-stop stimuli of city life may be inadvertently promoting short attention spans; there is simply too much going on vying for our ever-limited attention.

World map showing percent of population living in an urban environment.

In fact, according to environmental psychologist Stephen Kaplan (also of the Univ. of Michigan), attention is the crucial mediator between green space and psychological benefit. Urban environs place continuous demands on what’s known as directed attention. Natural environments, on the other hand, allow our directed attention to rest. What’s more, they engage a different form of attention that he calls fascination. This involuntary form of attention improves mood, directed attention and cognition.

Kaplan’s research has lead him to formulate his theory of restorative environments. These restorative settings have more biodiversity than a typical urban “green space” or city park, and they certainly provide stimulation–but not stimulation that provokes a negative emotional response. Simply put, this type of environmental stimuli allows our brains to relax. His theory is also known as attention restoration theory (ART).

An earlier study (Fuller et al) exploring the relationship between one’s mental health state (an effect termed reflection, i.e., the act of gaining perspective, clearing one’s head, etc.) and perceptions of green space diversity, showed a positive correlation between this reflection capacity and greens space biodiversity.*

It seems that the diversity in natural settings provides, or perhaps triggers, this different form of attention by providing a more interesting, but less stress-inducing, field of perception. Biodiversity, even in an urban environment, plays a key role in proper mental functioning.

Other studies of city dwellers have shown a positive correlation between having a view of trees and personal happiness. The field of environmental psychology has its roots in ecological psychology (founded in 1947 by Roger Barker) which sought to reveal how social settings influence behavior.

Environmental psychology studies such as these are now prompting urban designers to plan with Nature in mind (more green spaces, parks, bike trails) and to preserve natural features — such as trees — wherever possible. Organizations have emerged to specifically address the psychological needs of urban dwellers.

One such org, PPS (Project for Public Spaces), is a New York City based nonprofit (founded in 1975 by Fred Kent) that works to improve public spaces, particularly parks, civic centers, public markets, down towns, and campuses

Author’s note: I am fortunate to live in a moderate-sized city (Seattle) that provides rich cultural experiences AND easy access to natural environs; our “emerald city” has over 360 parks within its borders. In some of these, like Discovery Park and the Arboretum, one can actually get lost in, for a time.

* But no correlation between reflection and bird and butterfly diversity.
In general, the study found that more biodiverse and more complex green spaces better permitted personal reflection and provided more restorative benefit than did less diverse areas.

top photo: The Tuckerman Ravine trail at Mount Washington (New Hampshire), Ws47, on wikipedia.org; Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

middle  photo:  Chris 73 , on wikipedia.org, under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license

bottom photo: A bicycle trail in Granbury, Texas; public domain

population map:  Sbw01f ,  CC – BY – SA  3.0










About the Author

Michael Ricciardi is a well-published writer of science/nature/technology articles as well as essays, poetry and short fiction. Michael has interviewed dozen of scientists from many scientific fields, including Brain Greene, Paul Steinhardt, Arthur Shapiro, and Nobel Laureate Ilya Progogine (deceased). Michael was trained as a naturalist and taught natural science on Cape Cod, Mass. from 1986-1991. His first arts grant was for production of the environmental (video) documentary 'The Jones River - A Natural History', 1987-88 (Kingston, Mass.). Michael is an award winning, internationally screened video artist. Two of his more recent short videos; 'A Time of Water Bountiful' and 'My Name is HAM' (an "imagined memoir" about the first chimp in space), and several other short videos, can be viewed on his website (http://www.chaosmosis.net). He is also the author of the ebook 'Zombies, E.T's, and The Super Entity - A Selection of Most Stimulating Articles' and for Kindle: Artful Survival ~ Creative Options for Chaotic Times
  • Pingback: Want to Clear Your Head? Walks In Nature Are Proven To Be Better Than Walks In The City - The Fun Times Guide to Living Green()

  • This piece is really intriguing, especially since I live in Tokyo. I spend a great deal of time outdoors working on an urban organic farm about a two-minute walk from the nearest train station. I think there’s a great deal of truth in the need for natural spaces for reflection, reprieve, and learning. I find walking through the farm gates each morning that I suddenly relax and the city with its usual hustle and bustle moves to the outside. I can lose myself in the small fields and chestnut orchard the same as I would if I were hiking the nearby mountains. It’s not quite the same as hiking those mountains or when we spend time in Daisetsuzan National Park in Hokkaido, but it’s a good, close-to-home fix on a regular basis.

  • this is great it makes you learn more!

  • Pingback: 180 Groups Push Obama to Protect America’s Great Outdoors – Planetsave()

  • I’m reading this as I prepare to shut down my laptop and take a walk outside with my daughter, an unschooler. We live in very rural Maine and the leaves are beautiful right now, so we’ll head down to our swamp and look for frogs until we get hungry and head back with photos, something to tell Geek Daddy about, and peace of mind.

    This is one of the many reasons she learns outside of school. If she were in a public school, there would be no time for walks or quiet reflection – or frogs.

    Shine On,
    Lill

  • this is really a wonderful piece. gets more and more interesting the deeper you get into it. thanks a lot, Michael!